Not just critique, I'm not just going to critique you but self critique and how do we start to look at our portfolio in a really constructive way, where we can give ourselves some feedback. Which is really hard to do because it's hard to be objective about your work and impossible I would argue. You can't be totally objective about your work. But we're gonna talk about a few ways that you can take a fresh look at what you've been doing and figure out a way forward. And if you can't find a way forward, that's where other critiques come in and we're gonna help each other today, so what we're going to do is I'm gonna critique you four, who have been sort of like the stand in studio audience for everyone else out there who's watching. And you're gonna critique me and it's gonna be a really good thing, I hope. We're not gonna offend each other at all. Because I have the self critique checklist. And I'm hoping that this is going to really help us just going through the elements in the portfo...
lio that you'd want to look at, that you would want to make sure you check off your list if you're trying to figure out what's good, what's bad, what needs work, things like that. So we're going to be going through that and that's a bonus material self critique checklist that we have for our final segment, I'm so sad. Okay but let's talk about critique. Why, why bother critiquing? It's gonna give you better aim at your goals, which is an obvious thing. That's what you hope for from a critique. It can also break you soul into a million pieces if you get the wrong critique. So let's first of all recognize that there's almost always something valuable to be found in a critique, even if it might come at you from a harsh perspective. Technical advice, just literally improving your technique, which I think is probably one of the main reasons why people get critiques, is to improve their technique and their work flow, but I would argue that that's one of the simplest things to change and the simplest things to figure out about your own work. So I actually prefer to get critiques that are more centered on concepts and where my work is going to go after that. It helps you form an opinion of your own work and it helps you do that because essentially what you're doing is you're saying here critiquer person, here's my portfolio, what do you think? And the second somebody tells you what they think, you immediately form an opinion. Either yes I agree with that or no I don't agree with that. You know the feeling? I do this all the time with my friends. I'll be like, "oh I really want to make a picture, I don't know what to make a picture about, do you have any ideas?". And then they'll be like, "Okay yeah do this". And I'll be like, "No". They'll be like, 'Okay do this". I'll be like, "No way". And they're like, "You never take our ideas". And I'm like, "Yeah it's because I actually do know what I want, I just like to hear what I don't want". And that's what a critique is a lot of the time, where you're giving your images over and you're like what's good, then what's bad? And then they'll tell you and then you're either like I agree, or I definitely know that I don't agree with that person. And it's really good for that, it helps you form opinions about your work and you know right away if you feel strongly about something or if you don't. Clarity of vision, helping you to move forward in a way that feels really good, really authentic, really personal. Which images are the most popular. If you hand your portfolio over to enough people, eventually they'll start to say, "oh this one's my favorite, this one's not my favorite" and you'll probably start to get some consistent popular images cropping up. And then print worthiness. I had a review recently where I had my portfolio given to five different people and at the end of it nobody had mentioned this one print that was in there. They didn't say it was their favorite, they just kept moving right past it and the last person pulled out this image and she goes, "Get rid of this, this should not be in print, this is not good enough quality, do not print this image, don't keep it in your portfolio". She literally set it aside, she was like, "Don't even put it back in, put it somewhere else for now". I was like okay. You know what, two days later I sold that print. So you can't always trust people, but she was right about that print, it was not as good of quality as all the other prints. But sometimes the technique, the quality, sometimes those things take a back seat to how somebody emotionally feels towards something. So it's very difficult to get critiques because while she was absolutely correct about that image not being as good of quality, what she overlooked was the emotional tie that somebody might have to it. So, that's why critique is very, very difficult. So who can you trust? Everybody, everybody has something valuable to give. Now they might not give it in the most constructive way. They might now think of anything good to say right away. I've had my portfolio critiqued where we sit there in silence for way too long and you're very like, "Oh, what's gonna come of this, they can't even think of anything to say". And it's really, really scary. So I think that everyone can give something constructive. Everyone out there could look at your portfolio and say something that will positively impact the direction that you go. But at the same time, I don't trust anyone but myself. So this is a very confusing, conflicted set of emotions, because I'm very open to critique, I love being critiqued, I think it's massively helpful, but at the end of the day I can't listen to anyone, unless what they say aligns with my goals. And that's how I always judge a critique. Now I have a self critique check list and this is part of what you have in the bonus materials here. And this checklist is just really centering in on things that might need improvement, really big areas of connection with images and how can we work through that in a logical, technical way. Alright, overall cohesion. When you hand a portfolio over, they're going to expect there be cohesion from one picture to the next, to the next, all the way through to the end. Unless you're entering into a review, saying I have multiple portfolios here, they're going to expect one continuous portfolio that really works well together. So how do we determine cohesion? As we talked about in the printing segment, that there are ways of flowing form one image to the other be it visual or conceptual and either of those might apply to you portfolio. So whatever would make a series work together, same goes into your portfolio. Is there something that connects one to the other, to the other?